COVID-19 Records

Apr. 6, 2013 -- Took train to Philadelphia to attend the memorial Service for Chick Koop

Diary Prequel Package, p.309 · diary_prequel:entry:00850

Page text: p.309 · original PDF

Date
2013-04-06 00:00 (day precision)
Type
diary entry · diary
author
Anthony S. Fauci
Topics
Vaccines
Apr. 6, 2013 -- Took train to Philadelphia to attend the memorial Service for Chick Koop at the Tenth Presbyterian Church on 17" Street and Spruce Street. Chick was a dear friend and an historic figure. April 8 -- 14, 2013 -- Continual increase in cases of H7N9 flu from China. Virtually all chicken to human with about 20-30% fatality rate. HHS still not allowing me to do press on this for the usual reason that they say CDC has the lead. It is becoming clear that CDC is driving this obstruction. I am very sorry to hear that since this is really petty. An example is that on the evening of Sunday, April 14, WTOP contacted to me to be on their show at 7:05 AM on Monday, April 15. HHS said it should go to CDC even though WTOP is a local DC station!!! HHS gave it to Tom Frieden (Director of CDC) and just by chance, Tom called me at home on Sunday night at ~9:00 PM to talk about vaccines for H7N9 without even mentioning that he had been asked by HHS to do WTOP the next day.

Extracted statements

Rule-extracted, not adjudicated. The grade says what may be done with each one; read the document above before relying on any of them.

StatementGradeAttributionStance
HHS gave it to Tom Frieden (Director of CDC) and just by chance, Tom called me at home on Sunday night at ~9:00 PM to talk about vaccines for H7N9 without even mentioning that he had been asked by HHS to do WTOP the next day. quoted / not their view quoted_external message body appears to be pasted content asserts

In context

A single line often inverts meaning once you see what it answers, so neighbouring messages are always shown.

  1. 2013-03-23 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    Mar. 23, 2013 -- Gave my annual GWIDS lecture at Suburban Hospital. Have doing this for over 20 years. Also, this evening went to the Children's Inn Black Tie Gala and auction. Chris and I bided for and got (for $900.00) a beautiful tile enclosed mirror made by the children of the Inn.
  2. 2013-03-26 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    Mar. 26, 2013 -- Had what is becoming a "tradition" > dinner over my house with Harold Varmus and Eric Goosby. We used to include Gary Nabel, but he is gone to Boston with Sanofi. The tradition is that I cook pasta and either sausage or shrimp with great wines for the people (Harold, Eric, Gary) who are living in different cities from their wives. We spoke mostly about Eric's imminent stepping down from PEPFAR since he really wants to get back to San Francisco where his wife Nancy and his children are. He has done a magnificent job at PEPFAR and he should now do what makes him happy. Eric has become a dear friend.
  3. 2013-04-03 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    Apr. 3, 2013 -- Went to NYC to deliver the Weill Cornell Medical College Global Health Lecture on "HIV/AIDS: A Look to the Future". Met with medical students after the talk and rushed back to DC on last USAirways flight (9:00 PM) to leave for SF the next morning at 6:45 AM.
  4. 2013-04-04 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    April 4, 2013 -- flew to San Francisco to receive the UCSF Gold Medal along with Melinda Gates, Brian Druker (developed Gleevec), and Mary Ann Koda-Kimble (former Dean of UCSF School of Pharmacy). Gala affair at Pier 48 across the street from the new SF Giants Baseball stadium. I gave a 3 minute acceptance speech blasting the "sequestration" that many people said was eloquent and "courageous". I had flown to SF in the AM and took a taxi to Stanford to have lunch with Ali and buy her a birthday present at Lulu Lemon. Took CalTrain back to SF for the Gala. Ali is amazing -- straight A+ average.
  5. 2013-04-06 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci
    Apr. 6, 2013 -- Took train to Philadelphia to attend the memorial Service for Chick Koop at the Tenth Presbyterian Church on 17" Street and Spruce Street. Chick was a dear friend and an historic figure. April 8 -- 14, 2013 -- Continual increase in cases of H7N9 flu from China. Virtually all chicken to human with about 20-30% fatality rate. HHS still not allowing me to do press on this for the usual reason that they say CDC has the lead. It is becoming clear that CDC is driving this obstruction. I am very sorry to hear that since this is really petty. An example is that on the evening of Sunday, April 14, WTOP contacted to me to be on their show at 7:05 AM on Monday, April 15. HHS said it should go to CDC even though WTOP is a local DC station!!! HHS gave it to Tom Frieden (Director of CDC) and just by chance, Tom called me at home on Sunday night at ~9:00 PM to talk about vaccines for H7N9 without even mentioning that he had been asked by HHS to do WTOP the next day.
  6. 2013-04-10 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    April 10, 2013 -- Spoke at the Hart Building in the evening together with Astronomer Nancy Roman (87 years old). I spoke to people and students involved in a pro-education program in DC. Introduced by Edwin Grosvenor (President of the American heritage Society and former CEO of National Geographic Society. He loved my talk on "30 Years of HIV -- A personal Journey" so much that he said I definitely should write a book and offered his wife Elizabeth as my agent/publisher. She did Morton Kondrake's book about his wife Millie.
  7. 2013-04-11 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    April 11, 2013 -- James C. Hill Lecture given by Wafaa El-Sadr. Had lunch at Positano before the lecture. In the evening wend to the Lasker Board dinner at the Howard Hughes Institute Headquarters on Jones Bridge Road. I was asked with Harold Varmus to discuss the effects of the sequester on NIH.
  8. 2013-04-12 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    April 12, 2013 -- Sad day. Scheduled to get Whipple Procedure at Hopkins on April 15.
  9. 2013-04-13 00:00 Anthony S. Fauci open
    April 13-23, 2013 - For the past several weeks there has been intense activity regarding the situation with H5N1. General press not really involved, but Helen Branswell (Canadian Press) and Laurie Garrett as well as some bloggers are stoking the flames and coming up with mischief. USG (NIH/HHS/Amy Patterson) have put together a letter point-by-point countering the crazy accusations in Mike Osterholm's letter. Big discussion at HHS/NSS about whether to have Sec. Sebelius officially accept the NSABB recommendations about publishing the 2 papers. Out of respect for the Dutch, State Department wants to wait until the April 23-24 meeting of the Dutch for the announcement. Real circus → White House (Heidi Avery) want us to release the acceptance now; Dutch are now saying that they may not allow Fouchier to resubmit the revised manuscript to Science without an export control license; Fouchier says that this is basic research that is not controlled by export control and so threatens to release it to Science anyway. He can theoretically face a fine and 6 years in jail. HHS releases Secretary Sebelius's acceptance on Friday afternoon, April 20; however, in order to halfway not offend the Dutch, they have Francis Collins announce on the NIH Website that the Secretary has accepted the recommendations of the NSABB to publish without her actually saying it. Meanwhile, the bloggers (Helen Branswell and others) are accusing the USG of releasing it on a slow news time (Friday afternoon). I know that this is clearly not the case since they have been trying to get it out for days, but the bureaucracy has held it up. I have a Senate Hearing coming up on April 26 where much of this will get hashed out. I am getting extremely stressed by all of this since the really bad outcome would be if biomedical research on dual use issues will be severely impeded by somewhat hysterical responses to things that really are non-issues. Most of the people (scientists or not) really do not understand the issues of ferret experiments and their limitations and the extremely unlikely possibility of a bioterror attack with flu compared to the importance of doing and communicating science to prepare against the natural emergence of pandemic influenza. Just to reiterate, there have been so many aspects of this "perfect storm" surrounding the manuscripts: 1) Ron Fouchier's original over-selling the scary nature of this "I have here one of the most dangerous viruses in the world" likely and innocently trying to push his research and the paper. 2) The NSABB amazingly mis-reading the papers to believe that the aerosol-transmitted virus actually killed the animals upon aerosol transmission instead of only after intra-tracheal insertion of 1 million IDs. 3) The demagoguery of Mike Osterholm and his probable bi-polar hysteria leading the uninformed NSABB members. 4) The relative lack of influenza expertise of the NSABB members. 5) The scientific "hubris" of the influenza community, i.e. Peter Palese who believes (correctly) and says (unfortunately) that the non-influenza people are clueless. 6) The relative weakness of Paul Keim (good guy) as a Chairperson. 7) The opportunistic news people (Branswell - Canadian Press and Phil Boffey - NY Times). 8) The occasional incompetency of Amy Patterson in dealing with the NSABB even though everyone in the USG thinks that she is doing a great job. 9) The "bioterror-industrial complex" who sees bioterrorists everywhere and whose jobs depend on the fear of bioterror (Thomas Ingelsby - think tank; Tara O'Toole - DHS; multiple Beltway bandit companies, etc.).

Full conversation →